A proposed law in Britain banning conversion practices could expose parents, teachers and even children to criminal prosecution for conversations about gender identity, according to a report by the Policy Exchange think tank.
The draft Conversion Practices Bill, introduced by the British Government in June, seeks to prohibit attempts to change or suppress a person’s sexual orientation or gender identity through physical or psychological abuse. Those found guilty could face up to five years in prison.
However, Baroness Falkner, former chairman of the Equality and Human Rights Commission, has warned that the legislation is too broadly worded and could criminalise ordinary discussions between parents and children about gender identity.
In a report co-written with barrister Akua Reindorf KC, Falkner argued that the bill does not establish a minimum age for prosecution, raising concerns that children as young as 10 could face legal proceedings for comments or questions directed at classmates questioning their gender identity.
The report also suggests that parents could face prosecution for refusing to use a child’s preferred name, restricting their access to online content promoting gender transition or declining to finance gender reassignment procedures.
It further raises concerns about the legislation’s definition of gender identity, arguing that it could extend to a wide range of identities, including ‘catgender’, a term used by people who identify with or feel a strong connection to cats or other felines.
The report warns that, under the proposed legislation, someone could potentially face
imprisonment for attempting to persuade a person who identifies as ‘catgender’ that they are not, in fact, a cat.
Falkner described the proposed legislation as “ideological, authoritarian, unworkable and wholly unsuitable” for a democratic society.
She also argued that the bill could infringe on several fundamental rights, including freedom of expression, religious beliefs, the right to a fair trial and the right to family life.
The concerns have also been raised by other public figures and campaigners, who argue that the legislation could discourage parents and professionals from having open conversations with children about their gender identity.
Former Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch and Reform UK leader Nigel Farage are among those who have called for the proposed legislation to be scrapped.
However, the British Government has rejected the criticisms, describing the Policy Exchange report as misleading and based on inaccurate claims.
A Government spokesman said the bill targets a specific form of abuse and would not interfere with ordinary parenting.
“LGBT+ people should never, without exception, have to suffer coercion or abuse in an effort to change who they are,” the spokesman said.
The Government also maintained that the proposed legislation would not prevent open, exploratory or challenging conversations between young people and their parents, teachers, clinicians or pastoral leaders.
It added: “Successive governments have agreed for almost a decade that conversion practices have no place in modern Britain. This Government is finally delivering on this promise.”