Donations Disgrace: Melissa Relief food infested with weevils, expired crackers – Auditor General report

More than 200 bags of rice donated as relief for Hurricane Melissa victims were reported heavily infested with weevils, and hundreds of boxes of crackers were found past their best-before dates.

The findings are contained in the October 2026 compliance audit by Auditor General Pamela Monroe-Ellis, which has raised serious questions about the management, storage, distribution and accountability of humanitarian supplies donated in the aftermath of the Category Five hurricane.

The Office of Disaster Preparedness and Emergency Management (ODPEM) was unable to provide adequate records to establish whether donated relief supplies reached the people affected by Hurricane Melissa.

The findings are particularly significant given that ODPEM was reassigned to the Office of the Prime Minister (OPM) in November 2025, following the hurricane, with Prime Minister Andrew Holness citing the need for stronger coordination, logistical support and more centralised management of the national relief operation.

The move was intended to place the disaster response under closer central oversight, with the OPM positioned to coordinate the various government agencies and strengthen collaboration with the Jamaica Defence Force (JDF).

However, the latest audit has exposed substantial weaknesses in the agency’s systems for tracking and accounting for the very relief supplies it was expected to manage.

During a physical inspection of Warehouse 3 in June 2026, auditors found 359 boxes of crackers with best-before dates between March 4 and March 10, 2026.

The auditors also observed insects on consumable items, despite a fumigation exercise costing $450,000 having been carried out at the warehouse in May.

More troubling was an email dated March 23, 2026, in which ODPEM’s Logistics Manager formally alerted the Administrator that approximately 200 bags of rice were heavily infested with weevils.

The email warned that the infestation posed a significant risk to the remaining stock and could result in further deterioration if it was not addressed promptly.

Yet, according to the Auditor General, rice remained in storage about three months after the infestation was reported.

At the June stock count, auditors recorded 20,400 packs of rice, contained in 204 bags, while insects were still being observed on consumable items.

The Auditor General questioned the effectiveness and sustainability of the fumigation exercise and recommended that ODPEM obtain an assessment to determine whether the affected items were suitable for consumption.

The report does not establish that the infested rice or out-of-date crackers were distributed to hurricane victims. However, it raises serious concerns about the condition in which relief supplies were being stored, and the agency’s ability to monitor their safety and suitability.

The problems were not entirely new. The Auditor General noted that a 2024 performance audit had already identified weaknesses in ODPEM’s inventory management, including poor stock rotation, inadequate storage conditions, pests, mould, water damage and the storage of obsolete and damaged items alongside regular relief supplies.

That earlier audit also recorded ODPEM’s estimate that losses of relief items amounted to $3.9 million.

Beyond the condition of the food, the audit found that ODPEM was unable to provide a complete and verifiable trail showing that donated consumables had reached the communities and individuals for whom they were intended.

Of the 65 warehouse receipt forms submitted for internationally donated items, only two had supporting documentation, including commercial invoices, for goods valued at $19 million.

The agency did not provide receipt forms or other supporting documentation for locally donated items.

As a result, the Auditor General was able to validate only 2.2 per cent of the approximately $859 million in consumable donations ODPEM reported receiving.

The auditors also found that approximately $849 million in internationally donated relief items had not been recorded in ODPEM’s inventory records.

Although the agency provided 114 records showing the distribution of supplies to public and private entities, those documents did not identify the communities that benefited or the criteria used to determine who should receive the items.

The records also lacked monetary values, and ODPEM had not established procedures or reporting requirements to verify whether third-party recipients subsequently delivered the supplies to the intended beneficiaries.

The agency was therefore unable to demonstrate that donated food and other consumables had reached the people affected by the hurricane.

The auditors further found that ODPEM did not maintain proper store records showing the balance of goods in its warehouses. This meant they could not compare the physical stock count with the quantities received since November 2025 or the items distributed during the period under review.

The report concluded that, in the absence of complete and verifiable records, reasonable assurance could not be obtained that donated consumables had been properly received, accurately valued, fully accounted for and distributed to their intended beneficiaries.

Admin: